The short answer: reach for a cooling rub in the first days after a strain, a knock or a hard session, and whenever an area feels hot, swollen or freshly irritated. Reach for warmth when a muscle or joint feels stiff, tight and cold, typically first thing in the morning, before activity, or with the long-standing aches that come back week after week. The two do different jobs, and choosing the wrong one is the most common reason people say a muscle rub “did nothing”.
This guide explains what warming and cooling rubs actually do in the skin, what the research says about each, when to use which, and where CBD fits into a muscle rub. We make cooling CBD topicals at our laboratory in York Science Park and get asked this question in our shops every week, so we have included the honest version of what our products can and cannot do.
Table of Contents
- Warming vs cooling: the difference in one minute
- How cooling rubs work
- How warming rubs work
- When to use cooling and when to use warming
- What the research says about heat, cold and rubs
- Where CBD fits into a muscle rub
- How to apply a muscle rub properly
- How we do it at HempWell
- Frequently asked questions
Warming vs cooling: the difference in one minute
Neither type of rub changes the temperature of the muscle underneath by more than a fraction of a degree. What they change is the sensation in the skin, and through that, how the area feels and how you move it.
- Cooling rubs use ingredients such as menthol, peppermint and eucalyptus oil that trigger the skin’s cold-sensing nerves. The area feels cool and slightly numbed, which is why they suit fresh aches, post-exercise soreness and anything that feels hot or angry.
- Warming rubs use ingredients such as capsaicin (from chilli), methyl salicylate (wintergreen), camphor or cinnamon oil that trigger the skin’s heat-sensing nerves and open up surface blood vessels. The area feels warm and flushed, which is why they suit stiffness, tightness and the “cold and creaky” feeling.
Both are counter-irritants: they give the nervous system a strong, harmless sensation to attend to in place of the ache. The difference is the direction of the sensation, and that is what decides which one suits the problem in front of you. Tiger Balm is the product most people picture when they think of a muscle rub; it is a warming balm, and if you have used it you will know the sensation. Our balms and creams are the same style of product but cooling rather than warming, with CBD added, so they suit the opposite set of situations.

How cooling rubs work
The active ingredient in most cooling rubs is menthol, either as purified menthol or as a component of peppermint oil. A 2018 review in the Journal of Clinical Pharmacy and Therapeutics summarised the mechanism: menthol “is a selective activator of transient receptor potential melastatin-8 (TRPM8) channels”, the receptor in skin nerves that senses cold, and “as a topical agent, it acts as a counter-irritant by imparting a cooling effect and by initially stimulating nociceptors and then desensitizing them” (Pergolizzi et al., 2018). In plain terms, menthol makes the skin feel cold without being cold, and after the first tingle the local pain nerves quieten down.
That is a genuinely different thing from an ice pack, and in one small trial the rub came out ahead. Researchers gave 16 people with delayed-onset muscle soreness either a 3.5% menthol gel or ice on the sore arm; the menthol gel “decreased perceived discomfort to a greater extent and permitted greater tetanic forces to be produced” than ice (Johar et al., 2012). It was a small study and the effect is on how the muscle feels rather than on the injury itself, but it fits with what customers tell us: the cooling sensation makes a sore muscle easier to live with and easier to move.
Eucalyptus oil and other essential oils in cooling blends add to the sensation and the smell, and the carrier cream or balm does the practical job of carrying everything into the skin and making the area pleasant to massage.
How warming rubs work
Warming rubs work on the mirror-image receptor. Capsaicin “selectively activates the transient receptor potential vanilloid 1 (TRPV1)”, the heat-sensing channel in pain nerves, and at low concentrations it “induce[s] short-term defunctionalization of nociceptor terminals”, a temporary quietening of the local pain nerves that is “reversible within hours” (Arora et al., 2021). Methyl salicylate and similar “rubefacients” work differently again: they irritate the skin and dilate surface blood vessels, producing the red, flushed warmth that gives them their name.
The warmth people value from these rubs is partly the sensation and partly the effect that any gentle heat has on a stiff area: surface blood flow rises, tissue feels more pliable, and moving feels easier. That is why warming rubs are traditionally used before activity rather than after it.
One honest caveat. The Cochrane Collaboration reviewed the trials of salicylate rubefacients for muscle and joint pain and concluded that “the evidence does not support the use of topical rubefacients containing salicylates for acute injuries or chronic conditions”, while noting they “seem to be relatively well tolerated in the short-term” (Derry et al., 2014). The sensation is real and many people find it comforting; the evidence that the salicylate itself does more than that is thin. Capsaicin has better evidence, but mostly at high concentrations in prescription patches for nerve pain, not in over-the-counter rubs.
When to use cooling and when to use warming
| Situation | Cooling or warming? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A fresh sprain, strain or knock (first 2 to 3 days) | Cooling | The NHS advises ice in the first days and says to “avoid heat (such as hot baths and heat packs), alcohol and massages for the first couple of days”. A cooling rub follows the same logic. |
| Muscle soreness the day after exercise | Cooling | Post-exercise soreness responds to cooling; menthol matched or beat ice for comfort in the trial above. |
| A joint that feels hot, puffy or inflamed | Cooling | Heat on an already-hot area tends to feel worse. Cooling is the comfortable choice. |
| Morning stiffness, a tight neck or shoulders after a day at a desk | Warming | Stiff, cold tissue loosens with gentle warmth. Warming rubs or a warm compress suit this best. |
| Long-standing lower back ache with no fresh injury | Warming (or either) | Cochrane found “moderate evidence” that heat wrap therapy gives “a small short-term reduction in pain and disability” in acute and sub-acute low back pain. Many people alternate. |
| Before a run, match or gym session | Warming | Warmth before activity; cooling after. |
| Cramp or spasm | Warming | Warmth and gentle massage help a cramping muscle relax. |
If you are not sure which camp your ache falls into, ask two questions. Is it new, and does the area feel hot or swollen? If yes to either, cool it. If it is old, stiff and cold, warm it. And if it is a proper injury, follow the NHS advice on sprains and strains and see a GP if it is “getting worse or not feeling better after treating it yourself”.
What the research says about heat, cold and rubs
The evidence on temperature therapy is better than the evidence on any particular rub, so it is worth separating the two.
- Heat for back pain. The Cochrane review of superficial heat and cold for low back pain found “moderate evidence in a small number of trials that heat wrap therapy provides a small short-term reduction in pain and disability” and “insufficient evidence to evaluate the effects of cold for low back pain” (French et al., 2006). A large US evidence review reached the same conclusion, rating superficial heat as more effective than placebo for acute low back pain with moderate strength of evidence (Chou et al., 2016).
- Heat for post-exercise soreness. In a small trial, a low-level heat wrap worn after exercise reduced next-day pain intensity by 47% compared with no treatment, and in the treatment arm gave more pain relief than a cold pack (Mayer et al., 2006). The authors were clear it was “a small study”.
- Cold for recovery. A 2023 meta-analysis of 28 studies found cold water immersion “was superior to other recovery methods for recovering from muscle soreness” after strenuous exercise (Moore et al., 2023). An ice bath is a bigger intervention than a cooling gel, but the direction of travel is the same: cold after hard effort.
- Topical rubs overall. A Cochrane overview of topical analgesics found “good evidence that some formulations of topical diclofenac and ketoprofen are useful in acute pain conditions such as sprains or strains”, with a “strong message that the exact formulation used is critically important” (Derry et al., 2017). Those are pharmacy anti-inflammatory gels rather than warming or cooling rubs, and they are the right first port of call for a painful acute injury. Counter-irritant rubs sit alongside them for comfort, not instead of them.
The pattern across all of this is consistent: heat suits stiffness and long-standing ache, cold suits fresh injury and post-exercise soreness, and the rub you choose is a way of delivering one of those sensations conveniently, with a massage built in.

Where CBD fits into a muscle rub
CBD in a cream, balm or gel acts locally, in the skin and the tissue directly beneath where you apply it. Very little reaches the bloodstream, and that is the point of a topical: you target one area without taking CBD internally. Our guide to topical versus transdermal CBD explains the difference, and why patches are the exception.
The research on CBD topicals specifically is early and much thinner than the research on heat, cold or menthol. Laboratory work suggests cannabinoid receptors and related channels in the skin are plausible targets, and small studies in people report reduced discomfort, but there are no large randomised trials of a CBD cream for muscle pain yet. We set out the state of the evidence honestly in our scientific review of CBD creams, and our guide on which CBD format suits joint, muscle and nerve pain helps with choosing between a cream, a balm, a gel and a patch.
In practice, our customers use a cooling CBD cream the way they would use any good cooling rub, with the CBD as an extra ingredient in a formulation they would want anyway. The peppermint and eucalyptus do the cooling; the CBD, grapeseed oil and vitamin E make it a pleasant, nourishing cream to massage in. If you would like to compare strengths, our guide to strong versus mild CBD cream covers what the numbers on the bottle mean.
How to apply a muscle rub properly
- Wash and dry the area first and apply to intact skin only. Never use a warming or cooling rub on broken skin, a rash or a fresh wound.
- Start with a small amount, particularly with a warming rub, which can feel stronger than expected on thin skin. Build up rather than slathering it on.
- Massage in for a minute or two. The massage is part of the treatment, not just a way of spreading the product.
- Wash your hands afterwards and keep the product away from your eyes, mouth and anywhere sensitive. Capsaicin in particular lingers on fingers.
- No heat pad over a warming rub, and no ice pack over a cooling one for that matter. Doubling up can irritate or damage the skin.
- Two to four times a day is typical. Follow the directions on the product, and stop if the skin becomes red or sore beyond the expected flush.
Our step-by-step guides to using CBD cream and using CBD balm go into more detail for each format.
How we do it at HempWell
All of our muscle topicals are cooling, made in-house at our laboratory in York Science Park with CBD from hemp grown on our own farm in Europe:
- Cooling Muscle & Joint Cream in 500mg, 1000mg and 2000mg strengths. The same formula at every strength, cooling peppermint and eucalyptus oils in a grapeseed-oil and vitamin E cream, with only the CBD content changing. The 2000mg is our best-selling product. Around 140 applications per 100ml bottle.
- Muscle Balm in a 50ml glass jar, 500mg or 1000mg. A firmer, richer balm on a soya wax and cocoa butter base with eucalyptus, cajeput and mint oils. This is the closest thing in our range to the traditional tiger-style balm, but cooling rather than warming.
- Cooling Roll-On Gel, 500mg or 1000mg in 50ml. Hands-free, fast-drying and easy to carry, which makes it the one for gym bags and long journeys.
We do not currently make a warming rub, so if your ache is the stiff, cold kind, the honest advice is a warm compress or a warm bath first, then a cooling cream after activity if you want it. Every product is independently lab tested, with the reports published centrally on our lab reports page, and the range has been shaped with guidance from our Scientific Advisor, Professor Mike Barnes. If you want to try a cream alongside an oil, the CBD and Pain Starter Pack pairs a 50ml cooling cream with a 10ml Broad Spectrum oil and a booklet. Browse the full range of CBD topicals, and if you use a cream every day, a subscription saves 20%.
Frequently asked questions
Is a warming or cooling rub better for back pain?
For a fresh back strain in the first two or three days, cooling. For long-standing, stiff back ache, warming: Cochrane found moderate evidence that heat wraps give a small short-term reduction in low back pain. Many people with recurring back pain keep both and use each for what it does best.
Can you use a warming and a cooling rub together?
Not on the same area at the same time. Mixing the two, or putting a heat pad over a warming rub, can irritate the skin. Some people alternate them across the day, cooling after activity and warming before, which is fine as long as the skin has settled between applications.
Is menthol better than ice for sore muscles?
In one small trial, a 3.5% menthol gel reduced perceived discomfort more than ice and allowed the muscle to produce more force. Menthol makes the skin feel cold without actually cooling the tissue, so for a genuine acute injury the NHS advice to ice the area still applies.
Does a CBD muscle rub warm or cool?
It depends entirely on the other ingredients. CBD itself has no temperature sensation. Ours are cooling because they contain peppermint and eucalyptus oils; other brands make warming CBD rubs with capsaicin or camphor. Check the ingredients rather than the CBD content to know which you are buying.
Is Tiger Balm warming or cooling?
Classic Tiger Balm is a warming balm built on camphor and menthol with clove and cajeput oils, and it feels warm on the skin. Our Muscle Balm is the same style of product but cooling, with CBD and a eucalyptus, cajeput and mint blend, so the two suit different situations.
How long should you leave a muscle rub on?
You do not wash it off; it absorbs into the skin and the sensation fades over an hour or two. Reapply two to four times a day as directed, wash your hands after each use, and stop if the skin becomes red or sore beyond the expected tingle or flush.

